Reimagining the Paywall Experience

Led the redesign of LePal’s pricing page just before its official launch to build user trust and drive premium upgrades, achieving an 89% increase in likelihood to upgrade.

Role

Team Lead, UX Researcher & Designer

Team

5 UX Designers, 1 Project Manager

Timeline

1 week

Tools

Figma, Google Forms, Notion, Slack
The Problem

After LePal, an AI-powered mental health platform for Gen Z, introduced a paywall for its premium features, 80-90% of beta users reduced their usage or abandoned the app entirely.

Before
The Choose your plan screen before the redesign

An opportunity to reduce friction in the decision-making process

We discovered a vague value proposition, confusing pricing display, and unaddressed concerns left users hesitant to commit.

The Goal

Creating a clear, user-friendly paywall experience that builds trust, communicates the value of premium features, and increases subscription conversions among Gen Z users.

After
The Choose your plan screen after the redesign

The paywall that excites and informs

Overcoming user hesitancy and inspiring confidence through simplicity and transparency.

Process & Scope

Over the course of a 12-week fellowship program, my team completed 8 week-long design tasks, including recruiting approximately 40+ beta users, conducting comprehensive user research, and designing solutions focused on retention and engagement.

In the final week, I led my team in redesigning the paywall to improve conversion rates. Leveraging past findings, conducting targeted research, and iterating on solutions within a 7-day design sprint.

Objectives

  • Understand and cater to our target audience's preferences and expectations while balancing business goals.
  • Improve conversion rates by making the experience simple, clear, and appealing.

Initial Impact at a Glance

118% improvement in clarity
100% improvement in visual appeal
100% improvement in user confidence
89% increase in likelihood to upgrade
The redesigned paywall screen and "how your free trial works" screen
Research

Investigating the barriers to premium

Surveys, Interviews, & Usability Testing

What do users need to feel confident enough to upgrade?

Research began by gathering and organizing previous insights, conducting surveys with a total of 30 respondents along with interviews and usability testing with 3 of our Gen Z beta users.

Research Focus Areas

What we needed to learn most from users
  • Demographic information
  • App payment habits
  • Preferences around payment structures and incentives
  • Pain points in the current design
  • Willingness to pay for LePal and factors that affect this

Challenges

How I approached low participation

With limited incentives and time constraints, we struggled to recruit enough beta users in time. I broadened our reach and created an additional survey guide for the general public that could help us quickly gather more data on the preferences and behaviors of demographics.

Key Findings

Free Trial

Users prefer and expect free trials before committing, as it gives them a risk-free way to explore the app's value and decide if it's worth the cost.

Persuasive Value Proposition

Users not only need to know what premium includes, but why these features are significantly more beneficial to them.

Transparency

Privacy/data concerns have an impact on willingness to pay for a subscription, users want these concerns addressed before committing.

Clear Pricing

In order to confidently make a decision, users need clear, upfront costs and billing options presented in a simple, easy-to-understand way.

A look at pain points in the current flow

The original paywall flow starting at the homepage and ending with Choose your plan, with interactions highlighted
Pain points from testing are highlighted in annotations on the original design

Summary of Opportunities

  • Present billing options and pricing upfront with a clear and distinct hierarchy.
  • Simplify options and incentivize one with a % discount to reduce mental effort and build trust.
  • Communicate the value to the user in greater detail.
  • Use social proof to subtly guide and increase confidence.
  • Add a FAQ section to address concerns that affect willingness to pay.
  • Improve overall impression by fixing UI inconsistencies and decluttering the design.

...but one of the biggest barriers for our target audience came down to the cost (which was outside of our scope), here's how I addressed this:

Design Considerations

  • Highlight the value to justify the price point: Showcasing real user success stories through testimonials would strengthen credibility and demonstrate how the cost is worthwhile
  • Extend the free trial period from 7 to 14 days: LePal’s value lies in its ability to personalize the experience over time. A longer trial would allow users to see meaningful progress, build trust in the platform’s capabilities, and feel invested in its benefits.
  • Explain the free trial mechanics: This will lessen user fears about forgetting to cancel and build trust with the brand.

Future Research Opportunities

  • Investigate if the current value proposition is compelling enough to justify the price.
  • Explore whether beta users are representative of the broader target audience willing to pay for premium features.
  • Test alternative pricing strategies to better align with user willingness to pay.
Problem Scope

How might we design a clear and trustworthy paywall experience that communicates the value of premium features, reduces cognitive load, and aligns with Gen Z users' expectations and concerns?

Design principles to guide us

Clarity

Make benefits, pricing, and next steps crystal clear right away

Trust

Build confidence by proving credibility and reassuring users at every turn

Usability

Smooth out the journey, make it effortless to go from interest to action
Design Ideation

Exploring solutions

Wireframes

A paywall that's optimized for conversion rates

On day 4 I facilitated an ideation workshop with the team to create wireframes based upon our synthesized research findings. Focusing on the layout, structure, and incentives that can improve conversion rates.

Expanded view and normal view of paywall screens with annotations highlighting important redesign choices

How?

Simplifies decision-making: Minimizing billing options and emphasizing the annual plan as the best value reduces decision fatigue and boosts long-term revenue.
Addresses hesitations: Builds brand trust and lessens fears around committing to the premium subscription.
Intuitive and consistent UI: Improves credibility, aligns with the app's visual design, and keeps the focus on what matters.
Shows why premium is worth it: Users develop a good understanding of the potential benefits to them.   
V1
First version of our wireframe
V2
second version of our wireframe

I led a discussion as team members shared their initial sketches, exploring ways to refine or combine ideas. This led to Version 1 (left image), which I further refined into Version 2 (right image) based on feedback.

Key Design Changes:

  • Improved usability by creating a sticky footer with the CTA. This way the primary action is always accessible as users scroll through the information.
  • Eliminated ambiguity around pricing and highlighted the value of the annual plan more effectively.
  • Improved the copy using more engaging and specific language that aligns with user motivations and highlights the LePal's unique value.
A/B Testing

Turning our design into a clickable prototype, we asked 5 participants to explore the original and redesigned paywall.

Guiding Questions

What we needed to learn most from users
  • Which design is more appealing and understandable to users?
  • Does the new design increase likelihood and confidence to upgrade? If so, why?
  • Are there any usability issues or points of confusion in the redesign?

Measuring Impact

How we evaluated the redesign

Combining qualitative and quantitative data, we gathered thoughts, behaviors, and followed up with a survey asking users to rate the clarity, visual appeal, confidence in buying a subscription, and likelihood of subscribing on a five-point scale.

Key Finding

Clear trial details, upfront pricing, and a polished design boosted confidence—and likelihood to upgrade.

This early feedback underscored the power of simplicity and clarity in driving user decisions.

Before
Original paywall screen with a value proposition graphThe Choose your plan screen before the redesign
After
"Unlock your best self with LePal premium" with annual and monthly purchase optionsHow your Free Trial Works screen with the cute LePal buddy and detailed explanation of trial dates and what to expect

Preliminary Results

  • 118% improvement in clarity of information, with the average user rating increasing from 2.2 to 4.8
  • 100% increase in visual appeal, with the average user rating increasing from 2.4 to 4.8
  • 100% increase in users’ confidence to upgrade to a premium subscription, rising from an average of 2 to 4
  • 89% increase in likelihood to upgrade, rising from an average of 1.8 to 3.4

Next Steps

  • Test the final prototype with a broader group of target users and explore alternative approaches to address concerns about cost.
  • Refine the design further to clarify what features like Premium Chat include.
  • Track conversion rates and user engagement metrics over time to assess the redesign’s real impact on subscriptions.
  • Thorough research on competitors. By showing how LePal differentiates, conversion rates could be further improved.
Personal Feedback Survey

Insights from my team

After the fellowship program ended, I sent an anonymous survey to my team to gather their feedback on my leadership. Since it was my first time leading a design team, their insights were incredibly valuable in helping me grow and improve.

What did I do well as a team lead/designer?

Managing collaborative sessions, being so organized and on top of things, great communication skills
I loved how you were assigning tasks, managing schedules, providing feedback, and ensuring effective collaboration among team members
Your approach to weekly meetings is well-structured and providing the team with additional information helped greatly in designing the wireframes

What could I improve on?

Maybe being more assertive in following up with the tasks and motivating people to finish them
You did great as a team leader, I don't have anything specific where you can improve
Looking back, I believe there should be more design critiques and collaborations in designing a singular wireframe
Reflection

Lessons learned along the way

01

Balance Collaboration with Accountability

I’ve always been good at creating a supportive, collaborative environment, but I realized I could be more proactive in following up on tasks. If I were in a leadership position again, I plan to introduce regular check-ins and clarify task ownership to keep things moving without affecting team morale. Striking this balance is crucial for delivering projects on time while keeping everyone engaged and motivated.

02

Stay flexible

Projects rarely go exactly as planned, and leading the team meant adapting quickly to challenges like low research participation or shifting project constraints under tight deadlines. I learned that staying flexible, reprioritizing tasks, and finding creative solutions — while always being mindful of the tradeoffs — helps keep the team focused and productive.

Let's Connect!

Send me an email